Believe It-It’s Not Butter
Due to a scarcity of butter in 1869, Frenchman Napleon III offered a prize to anyone who could invent an inexpensive substitute for butter. Hippolyte Mege-Mouries won when he presented his beef suet and milk called oleo margarine. Although flavorful, the margarine was an unappealing, grayish color so Hippolyte added yellow food coloring to make it more appetizing. It was a huge success in France, which motivated the manufactures to begin marketing their inexpensive product world wide.

- Image via Wikipedia
In the 1870s, the grayish butter substitute made its way to America and was becoming quite a hit. Well, at least until in true capitalistic spirit, the US dairy industry lobbied against it. They asked the federal government to restrict the sale of margarine, tax it, and ban the yellow food coloring so that the putrid gray color was the only color that Americans would see. This lobbying was effective in keeping sales down until the 1930s, and then all bets were off.
By the 1960’s, margarine sales were solidly gaining market share because it was inexpensive. Conversely, butter sales were quickly melting. During World War II margarine went on to become an American staple because it was branded as a “healthy alternative to butter.” Albeit- healthier when vitamin A and D was eventually added to it. Everyone was happy and healthy with this cheap new substance- or were they? Cardiologist soon discovered that margarine was anything but nutritiously healthy.
At the beginning of the 1900s, deaths from heart attacks were extremely rare. Conversely, during the 1940’s, 1950’s and 1960’s, middle aged men and post menopausal women were frequently dying from heart attacks. Cardiologists linked these deaths to the increased consumption of margarine due to the hydrogenated oils and trans-fatty acids that it contained. What are trans-fats?
According to the FDA, trans-fat is made when manufacturers add hydrogen to vegetable oil–a process called hydrogenation. Hydrogenation increases the shelf life and flavor stability of foods containing these fats and it creates the right “feel and texture” in your mouth. Trans-fats are found in most baked goods such as cakes, cookies, crackers, salad dressings, candies like sprinkles, breakfast cereals, shortening, margarine, and potato chips, etc. While these foods’ shelf lives will probably out live us, and they taste sinfully good- are they good for us?
The answer is a blood curdling NO. As mentioned earlier, trans-fats are linked to cardiovascular disease and it restricts blood flow through the arteries. According to Dr. Andrew Weil, a resent research paper in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology makes the possible consequences of this situation scarily clear. Australian investigators gave subjects three different meals containing measured portions of fat. The first meal came from a deep fryer in a restaurant, the second meal had the same amount of fat but it was uncooked, and the third meal was low fat. Four hours after the meals, the researchers measured the blood flow through the brachial artery- the main artery supplying the arm. They found significant restriction of blood flow in subjects who ate the fast food meal, some blood flow restriction in those who ate the uncooked meal, and no restriction from the low fat meal. They interpreted that the restriction of blood flow was due to the oxidative stress resulting from toxic compounds entering the blood after eating the high trans-fat meal from the restaurant.
So use your noggin! The next time you go food shopping, don’t just look at the label-also read the list of ingredients. If you see any ingredient with hydrogenated or partially hydrogenated oil of any kind, run in the other direction (while you still can) and find a healthier alternative. Lastly, try to avoid eating in restaurants as much as possible because 99% of the time, you will be eating a sinfully delicious cocktail of cancer causing preservatives, and blood pressure raising salt, and artery clogging trans-fat.
References
(2003, September-October). Revealing Trans Fats. FDA Consumer Magazine .Vol 37, Number 5. Retrieved January 28, 2009 from http://www.fda.gov/fdac/503_toc.html
Nestle, M. What to Eat. New York. North Point Press, 113-11.
Weil, A. Eating Well For Optimum Health: The Essential Guide to Food, Diet, and Nutrition. New York. Random House, 79 and 90.
FYI About the Author: Toni Hall Parker graduated from Smith College with a psychology degree and managed recruiting for various pharmaceutical companies’ North American region. She began self-studying nutrition in 2003 and attended the Institute for Integrative Nutrition in New York in 2008 to become a Holistic Health Counselor. She now resides in Dallas, Texas with her family. For more information, please visit her website at www.myfoodtherapy.com
February 10th, 2009Topic: Features, Healthy Recipes Tags: living naturally, Margarine, natural mom, Trans fat, Vegetable fats and oils
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=691bae1c-8156-41ee-9bdb-22f395a9577e)

February 18th, 2009 at 5:07 am
[...] in France, which motivated the manufactures to begin marketing their inexpensive product world wide.Believe It-It’s Not Butter, Feb [...]
February 20th, 2009 at 7:11 pm
I love butter and since it is good for me and my weight loss I eat it as often as I can. Unfortunately, the things to spread it on are limited for me because bread hates me, but I can cook my eggs in it.
Also good for you that was always labeled as bad by the mass marketing veggie oil media and the government is coconut oil. Of course, it can’t be partially hydrogenated as you said above. Palm oil is good too. The food service did us a disservice by telling everyone that butter, coconut, and palm oils are bad for you. And all this time they hailed the butter substitutes and banished the butter. Shame on them! Now wonder why a good portion of the USA is obese and sick.
Great article!
February 24th, 2009 at 11:21 am
‘Lastly, try to avoid eating in restaurants as much as possible because 99% of the time, you will be eating a sinfully delicious cocktail of cancer causing preservatives, and blood pressure raising salt, and artery clogging trans-fat’
wow really? Then again anything that tastes so good usually is really bad for you
Sally’s last blog post..Fighting Mortgage Repossession Is A Battle
March 24th, 2009 at 8:15 am
Not only is margarine high in trans fatty acids, it lowers the quality of breast milk, decreases the immune system response, diminishes insulin response, and like you say there is much evidence that indicates it places you at risk of coronary heart disease.
July 20th, 2009 at 3:47 pm
I am a butter eating advocate!!! Would never have the other stuff in my refrigerator. Had an experience over 20 years ago with butter and margerine. A single mom, ran short on funds and purchased a pound of margerine….placed it on the kitchen counter to soften. It was summer, we didn’t have air conditioning, and about 90 degrees that day. When I was ready to prepare dinner, the margerine was soft and in tact in the wrapper. I was shocked because I had a previous experience where I’d left butter on the counter in warm weather; it had melted and was all over the place. My first thought when I saw the margerine was if it doesn’t melt in warm weather, it’s doing the same thing inside my body. The end of margerine for me. I had an uncle who lived to 89 years of age, and was bitterly against margerine. The proof is in the pudding!!!! Butter for me and mine!!!